Quantcast
Channel: Thrifty Traveler
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 726

American Express® Gold Card vs The Platinum Card® from American Express: Which is Best For You?

$
0
0

The *amex gold* and *amex platinum* are Amex's top two travel cards and easily rank among the best rewards cards … from any bank. But when it comes to a head-to-head showdown between the two, there is a lot to consider.

Both cards come from the same bank and earn the same American Express Membership Rewards points, but the point-earning and benefits on each card, as well as their price tags, are drastically different. Of course, nothing is stopping you from holding both cards. But many travelers want to choose between them … at least to start.

So let's compare the Amex Gold and Platinum cards to help you understand how they differ, how they're alike, and most importantly, help you decide which version is best for you.

 

 

Amex Gold vs Amex Platinum: Overview

 

BenefitAmex PlatinumAmex Gold
Welcome Offer*amex platinum bonus*bonus_miles_full
Bonus Point EarningEarn 5x Membership Rewards on flights up to $500,000 in purchases per calendar year and 5x on prepaid hotels booked through Amex TravelEarn 4x Membership Rewards on dining worldwide (up to $50,00 per year), Earn 4x at U.S. supermarkets (up to $25,000 per year), Earn 3x on airfare (purchased direct or through Amex Travel), Earn 2x on prepaid hotels, rental cars, and cruises booked through Amex Travel
Standard Point Earning1x Membership Rewards point per dollar spent1x Membership Rewards point per dollar spent
Statement Credits$200 hotel credit, $200 airline fee credit, $240 digital entertainment credit, $200 Uber Cash, $100 Saks Fifth Avenue credit, $300 Equinox credit, $155 Walmart+ credit, $199 CLEAR Plus credit, and more (terms & conditions apply to all credits)$120 dining credit, $120 Uber Cash, $100 Resy credit, $84 Dunkin' credit (terms & conditions apply to all credits)
Lounge AccessComplimentary access to American Express Centurion Lounges, Delta Sky Clubs (when flying Delta), Escape Lounges, Plaza Premium Lounges, and Priority Pass LoungesNone
Foreign Transaction FeesNoneNone
Annual Fee$695 (see rates & fees)$325 (see rates & fees)

 

Welcome Offers

Both the Amex Gold and Platinum Cards currently come with welcome offers worthy of your attention.

But before you dive in, remember: Credit cards are serious business. No matter how big the bonus is, you should never open a new credit card and spend thousands of dollars for the sake of earning points unless you can afford to pay off every dime in full.

 

American Express Gold Card

bonus_miles_full

But you can potentially get an even bigger welcome bonus offer by utilizing CardMatch. Available exclusively from the CardMatch tool from creditcards.com, you might be targeted for a 75,000-point welcome offer through CardMatch or even see offers as big as 100,000 points when applying through a personal referral link.

 

The American Express Gold Card on top of a passport

 

It seems those who have never held an American Express card previously have the best chance of getting targeted. So again, this new bonus offer is great and certainly better than the standard offer. Just make sure you check all available offers before applying.

Even if you aren’t eligible for the 75,000-point offer through CardMatch, you can still get the 75,000-point bonus (plus earn a $250 statement credit on purchases made at restaurants in your first 12 months) by applying for the Gold Card through Resy!

Read More: Huge! Earn 100K Points (& up to $100 Credit) with Amex Gold Referral Offer

 

The Platinum Card from American Express

bonus_miles_full

And just like with the Amex Gold Card, you can potentially get a bigger welcome bonus offer by utilizing CardMatch, where we've seen offers for 175,000 points after spending $8,000 in the first three months. That said, the Amex Platinum 175,000-point offer won't be available for all users. Some may be targeted for lower offers like 125,000 or the standard offer of 80,000 points, while others may not see anything for the Platinum Card through CardMatch at all.

Even if you aren’t eligible for the 175,000-point offer, you can get a 100,000-point bonus (plus earn a whopping 10x points per dollar spent on the first $25,000 spent at restaurants in six months) by applying for the Platinum Card through Resy!

Read More: Get an Amex Platinum 175K Bonus: Use CardMatch for a Bigger Platinum Card Offer

 

Winner: Which Welcome Offer is Best?

Comparing the welcome bonuses on the Amex Gold and Platinum might seem pretty clear cut but with so many different offers available, it's a lot harder than it looks. While both cards are currently offering big bonuses, the best offer on the Platinum Card is better than the best offer on the Gold Card.

But even with a bigger bonus, it might make more sense to start with the Amex Gold. Generally speaking, you can earn a welcome offer on every Amex card once per lifetime – but after some recent changes, you'll need to do it in the right order. If you go straight to the top and pick up the Amex Platinum, you'll be ineligible for a welcome offer on the Amex Gold later on down the road.

Still … bigger is sometimes better – and the Amex Platinum's welcome offer is definitely that. That gives it the slight edge in this category.

 

*amex platinum*

 

Learn more about *amex platinum*.

 

Annual Fee

The annual fee on the American Express Gold card is $325 (see rates & fees). While that might sound steep, we've crunched the numbers and come to the conclusion it can easily be worth it.

Meanwhile, the yearly fee on the Platinum Card is about as high as it gets. It clocks in at $695 per year (see rates & fees) … and no, it's not waived for the first year.

Want to add an authorized user to your card? There is no charge for doing so with the Amex Gold but with the Amex Platinum, you'll pay $195 for each additional card you add. But there's a reason the cost is so high: Those cards will get many of the same benefits as the primary cardholder.

If you're not looking to shell out nearly $200 per year on top of a nearly $700 annual fee, you also have the ability to add free companion Platinum card authorized users at no cost. However, those users won't get most of the benefits that the full-fledged authorized user cards come with.

Read more: Is the Amex Platinum Card Worth the $695 Annual Fee?

 

Winner: Which Card's Annual Fee is Best?

If you are just looking at the upfront out-of-pocket cost to hold either card each year, the Amex Gold wins in a landslide. It's nearly $400 cheaper than the Platinum Card from American Express.

But whether the annual fee is worth it for you is all about whether or not you can maximize all the benefits the card offers. While the annual fee on the Platinum Card is $695, it offers a ton of value which can easily make the card worth having.

 

*amex gold card*

 

Learn more about the *amex gold*

 

Earning Points

While both the Amex Gold and Platinum Cards earn the same kind of points, just how fast you rack them up will depend on which card you carry.

 

American Express Gold Card

The Amex Gold Card is a great choice for anyone who likes food. I know that sounds dumb, but you'll see why in a second.

First off, you'll earn 4x Membership Rewards Points per dollar spent at restaurants worldwide (on up to $50,000 spent each calendar year, then 1x). That includes delivery services like DoorDash, Uber Eats, and more. Plus, you'll earn 4x Membership Rewards Points per dollar spent at U.S. supermarkets on up to $25,000 of spending each calendar year (then 1x).

This means that no matter if you're cooking at home or dining out, you're earning best-in-class rewards on all your food expenses – two huge spending categories for many Americans. You'll be hard-pressed to find a card that offers a better return on both your grocery and restaurant bills.

You'll also earn 3x Membership Rewards Points per dollar spent on flights booked directly with the airline or through amextravel.com. And 2x Membership Rewards points on prepaid hotels, rental cars, and cruises booked through amextravel.com.

All other eligible purchases earn 1x point per dollar spent.

Read more: A Full Review of the American Express Gold Card

 

The Platinum Card from American Express

With the Amex Platinum Card, you'll earn 5x Membership Rewards Points per dollar spent on flights booked directly with the airline or through amextravel.com. For this reason (and many more), we think it is the best card for booking airfare. Additionally, you'll earn 5x points per dollar on prepaid hotels booked through amextravel.com.

You'll earn 1x point per dollar spent on all other eligible purchases.

Read more: A Full Review of the Platinum Card from American Express

 

Winner: Which Card is Best for Earning Points?

Unless you spend a lot on airfare, the Amex Gold Card wins this one in a landslide. Earning 4x points per dollar spent at U.S. supermarkets and at restaurants worldwide is really second to none. In the long term, it'll earn you more points and make more sense for your everyday spending.

 

*amex gold card*

 

Learn more about the *amex gold*

 

Redeeming Points

When it comes to using your points, there is no advantage to holding one card over the other.

No matter whether you redeem your points directly through the Amex travel portal or transfer them to nearly two dozen airline or hotel transfer partners, you've got identical options with these two cards. Booking direct with amextravel.com, each point is worth 1 cent apiece. That's a departure from Chase, which gives cardholders of the *chase sapphire reserve* a bigger bonus than the *chase sapphire preferred* when booking travel with points.

Meanwhile, here's a full list of American Express Membership Rewards transfer partners.

 

ProgramTypeTransfer RatioTransfer Time
Aer LingusAirline1:1Instant
AeroMexicoAirline1:1.63-5 days
Air Canada AeroplanAirline1:1Instant
Air France/KLMAirline1:1Instant
ANAAirline1:11-2 days
AviancaAirline1:1Instant
British AirwaysAirline1:1Instant
Cathay PacificAirline1:1Instant
DeltaAirline1:1Instant
EmiratesAirline1:1Instant
EtihadAirline1:1Instant
HawaiianAirline1:1Instant
IberiaAirline1:1Up to 24 hours
JetBlueAirline1.25:1Instant
QantasAirline1:1Instant
Qatar AirwaysAirline1:1Instant
SingaporeAirline1:1Instant
Virgin AtlanticAirline1:1Instant

 

Make sure to read our post on the best ways to redeem Membership Rewards Points.

 

Winner: Which Card is Best for Redeeming Points?

This category is a tie. When it comes time to use your points, neither card has an edge in this category.

 

Statement Credits

Justifying a big annual fee on a credit card boils down to whether the benefits outweigh the cost. And monthly and annual statement credits on both the Gold and Platinum Cards can go a long way.

American Express Gold Card

With the Amex Gold, you'll get up to $120 in dining credits each year to spend at Grubhub, The Cheesecake Factory, Goldbelly, Wine.com, and Five Guys. This credit is broken up into increments of up to $10 per month. Simply use your gold card at any of these places and automatically get credited back up to $10 each month.

As part of the Amex Gold Card's recent refresh, you'll now get up to $100 per year in Resy credit, with up to $50 in credit available every six months (January to June and July to December). To use this credit, you'll first need to enroll on your card's benefits page in your Amex account. After that, it's as simple as using the card to pay at any U.S. Resy participating restaurant. After doing so, you should receive a statement credit within a few days.

 

resy app on phone

 

The Amex Gold Card also comes with a new credit of up to $84 per year to be used at Dunkin' – the artist formerly known as Dunkin' Donuts. Just like most Amex credits, this one is broken up into increments of $7 per month. You'll also need to enroll in this benefit before swiping your card at Dunkin' – but once you do, you're all set. Any purchases, up to $7 per month, will automatically generate a credit from Amex.

 

Amex Gold Credit Card

 

Finally, you'll get up to $120 annually in Uber cash to use at both Uber and Uber Eats. These statement credits are given out in $10 monthly increments. Just add your Gold Card to your Uber account, and each month, automatically get $10 in Uber Cash for Uber Eats orders or Uber rides in the U.S.

Critically, all these monthly and semi-annual statement credits are use-them-or-lose-them benefits: They won't rollover from month-to-month.

But add it all up and you've got over $400 in statement credits at your disposal – enough to cover the full $325 annual fee … and then some. These credits and bonus categories are a big reason why we feel the card is still worth its $325 annual fee.

 

The Platinum Card from American Express

If you thought there were a lot of credits to manage on the Amex Gold card, just wait until you see what the Amex Platinum has to offer.

Similar to the Gold Card, you'll get up to $200 in Uber Cash to use on Uber rides or Uber Eats food delivery. It's broken up into increments of $15 per month – but that jumps to $35 in December. Just like with the Gold Card, any remaining balance at the end of the month is forfeited.

Further, each year you hold the Platinum Card, you'll get up to $200 in airline fee credit to use with one selected airline. The credit is intended to be used for things like checked bags, change or cancelation fees, seat assignments, lounge access, and more. Unfortunately, buying airfare outright won’t work – nor will cabin upgrades, buying miles, and several other similar purchases. Thankfully, there are some creative ways to put these credits to use beyond what they're officially intended for.

This credit resets each calendar year, so every January, you will get a fresh $200 to use. If you have any remaining credit from the previous year, it won’t carry over.

 

amex gold vs platinum comparison

 

With the Amex Platinum, you'll also get up to a $120 credit to cover the cost of either Global Entry or TSA PreCheck. Membership in either program is good for five years and this credit can be used once every four years. So which should you choose? If you hope to do any international travel, Global Entry should be your choice as it includes TSA PreCheck.

You'll also receive an annual credit of up to $199 to cover the cost of CLEAR® Plus. Whether or not CLEAR is worth the cost is certainly up for debate, but getting it fully covered just for holding the Amex Platinum Card is a nice perk.

You'll receive up to $200 per year in credit for hotels booked through Amex Fine Hotels + Resorts – or with The Hotel Collection, when booking two nights or more.

Each year, you will also get up to $100 in statement credits to spend at Saks Fifth Avenue: $50 from January through June, and another $50 to spend from July through December. Again, this is a use-it-or-lose-it benefit.

You'll get up to $240 in statement credits each month for digital entertainment when you pay for eligible services like Peacock, The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, The Disney Bundle, ESPN+, and Hulu.

Finally, you'll get up to $155 per year towards a Walmart+ membership each year. This is dolled out in the amount of $12.95 each month.

Read more: What Went Wrong with CLEAR (& When Will It Get Better)?

 

Winner: Which Card Offers More Statement Credits?

Add up all the credits on the Platinum Card, and you can get over $900 back in your first year, though the final sum depends on when you opened your card and your ability to actually use some of these benefits. But no matter how you slice it, you can easily come out ahead on the otherwise steep $695 annual fee.

 

*amex platinum*

 

Learn more about *amex platinum*.

 

Lounge Access

If you're looking to get into airport lounges this is no contest at all. That's because the American Express Gold Card will not get you access to any airport lounges.

The Amex Platinum Card, on the other hand, is arguably the best credit card to get into airport lounges, period. No other credit card opens more airport lounge doors than this one.

To start with, you'll have access to American Express's signature Centurion Lounges.

 

los angeles centurion amex gold vs platinum
The complimentary bar at the Los Angeles (LAX) Amex Centurion Lounge

 

These lounges are scattered throughout the U.S. at more than a dozen airports and counting – plus, Amex has a growing list of international outposts like Hong Kong (HKG) and London-Heathrow (LHR). When they first debuted, Centurion Lounges put most other airline lounges to shame, but more recently they've lost a step as competition from other banks like Capital One and Chase has heated up. Even still, you can always count on free food and drinks … even if there is a wait to get in.

The Amex Platinum Card also comes with a Priority Pass Select membership that will allow you and up to two guests to access over 1,300 airport lounges around the globe. While most Priority Pass Lounges aren't as nice as Amex's own Centurion Lounges, they're still a great place to relax and get a light bite before catching a flight.

 

priority pass lounge
The El Dorado Lounge in Bogotá, Colombia is a part of Priority Pass

 

Next, you will get access to the Delta Sky Clubs – but only if you are flying Delta that day. Right now, Amex Platinum cardholders get unlimited complimentary access to Delta's Sky Clubs, but that will be changing in early 2025 when each cardholders will be capped at 10 visits per year … unless you're willing to spend $75,000 per year on your Platinum Card.

 

Skyclub Austin Texas
The Delta Sky Club in Austin (AUS)

 

Finally, you will get access to several smaller lounge networks including Plaza Premium, Air Space, and one of our favorites, Escape Lounges – The Centurion Studio Partner. These lounges are at a growing list of airports around the country, including our home airport of Minneapolis/St. Paul (MSP).

 

Escape Lounge MSP
The Escape Lounge at Minneapolis/St. Paul Airport (MSP)

 

Winner: Which Card is Best for Lounge Access?

This category isn't really a competition. Considering the Amex Gold Card doesn't offer any sort of lounge access, the Amex Platinum Card is the best (and only) option for accessing airport lounges and making your entire experience at the airport better.

 

*amex platinum*

 

Learn more about *amex platinum*.

 

Elite Status Perks

If you're on the hunt for hotel or car rental status, the Platinum Card really starts to pull away.

Just as with lounge access, the American Express Gold Card will not get you any sort of elite status perks or benefits. On the other hand, just for holding the American Express Platinum Card, you will receive complimentary Marriott Bonvoy and Hilton Honors Gold status. While Marriott Gold won't get you much in the way of benefits, Hilton Gold does come with free breakfast when traveling abroad or a daily food and beverage credit at U.S. hotels.

You’ll also get elite recognition in a couple of rental car programs, including National Emerald Club Executive status and Hertz President's Circle status.

With National, you get a handful of benefits, but one stands out: Access to the Executive Area and the ability to completely skip the rental car counter upon your arrival. Skipping the lines at the counter and mountains of paperwork is a huge time saver. You can simply walk off the plane, head to the car rental area, select your car, and go.

executive access area text

 

As long as you book at least the midsized car rate, you’ll have access to any vehicle in the Executive area for no additional charge! Emerald Club Executive members are also guaranteed a free upgrade in the U.S. and Canada – assuming you book at least a midsized car.

Similar benefits are available through Hertz so be sure to price shop with your next rental.

 

Winner: Which Card is Best for Elite Status?

Again, this category isn't particularly close. The Amex Gold Card doesn't offer any sort of elite status perks while the Platinum Card offers complimentary Marriott and Hilton Gold status, and National Executive Elite status just for holding the card.

 

*amex platinum*

 

Learn more about *amex platinum*.

 

Bottom Line

By the numbers, the Platinum Card takes four categories while the Gold Card wins two, and one was a draw. So does that make The Platinum Card the obvious winner? Not necessarily.

Everyone can – and should – weigh these categories differently. For some, earning 4x points at restaurants and supermarkets may make the Gold Card the better choice, especially considering its lower price tag. For others, lounge access and hotel status might make the Platinum Card the clear favorite, despite its high cost.

It's important to select the card that makes the most sense for you and how you plan to use it.

 


Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 726

Trending Articles